Compare
Income Lab alternatives: retirement income planning tools advisors evaluate
Advisors evaluating Income Lab (Income Laboratory, Inc.) often compare it with Quantum Portfolio Analytics, Holistiplan and RightCapital. This page lists what each vendor documents about its own product, with the source page and the date it was read.
Retirement income and Roth conversion software for financial advisors models a household's income sources, taxes and withdrawals year by year so an advisor can compare strategies before recommending one.
Published by Quantum Portfolio Analytics · Last reviewed 2026-11-09
How to read this page
- Every row states what a vendor documents on its own public pages; nothing comes from reviews, rankings or third-party articles.
- "Not documented publicly" means the vendor's public pages did not describe that capability on the date they were read. It does not mean the product lacks it.
- Each cell links to the page it was read from. Facts were last reviewed on 2026-11-09; list prices are as published by each vendor on the date shown in the cell.
What each vendor documents
| Capability | Income Lab (Income Laboratory, Inc.) | Quantum Portfolio Analytics | Holistiplan | RightCapital |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Retirement income / distribution planning | Income planning with spending guardrails and stress testing. source | Models retirement income across Social Security, pensions, and portfolio withdrawals. source | Not documented publicly source | Tax-Efficient Withdrawals; apply distribution strategies; pension option comparisons. source |
| Multi-year Roth conversion modeling | Bracket management strategies use Roth conversions to fill a target federal bracket. source | Modeled Conversion Options sized to a federal bracket, priced year by year with the full tax engine, and compared over a lifetime. source | Fill a Tax Bracket or IRMAA Threshold, with a First Year and Last Year of Conversion. source | Model dynamic Roth conversions up to ordinary income, capital gains, or Medicare premium brackets, with conversion start and end years. source |
| Medicare IRMAA modeling | IRMAA bracket strategies target a Medicare premium tier, applying the two-year lookback from the fourth plan year. source | Yes source | Medicare looks at income (in the form of MAGI) from two tax years prior; Holistiplan defaults to applying the most recent officially released brackets and surcharges. source | RightCapital will calculate IRMAA penalties on Medicare premiums when a Medicare option is selected for the retirement medical expense goal. source |
| Social Security taxation | IRMAA, federal tax, state tax and Social Security taxation interact. source | Yes source | Not documented publicly source | Combined income is defined as the client's AGI plus non-taxable interest plus 50% of Social Security benefit. source |
| RMD modeling | Yes source | Yes source | Not documented publicly source | Not documented publicly source |
| Federal tax projection | Federal ordinary and long-term capital gains income taxes. source | Full recomputation of federal and state income tax for each modeled year, not a marginal-rate shortcut. source | Project tax impacts and liabilities down to the dollar; Scenario Analysis models possibilities for next tax season. source | Projected Tax Returns — view mockups of the 1040 and various schedules for each year and across each proposal. source |
| State income tax coverage | Tax Lab models state income tax for all 50 states and DC, next to federal tax, capital gains and IRMAA. source | Federal and all 50 states plus DC. source | State Tax Modeling is available to those subscribed to a Premium Plan; all state tax modeling must be done within Scenario Analysis. source | State-specific tax rates, deductions, and exemptions for all states, applied by the state in which the client resides. source |
| Capital-gains stacking | Yes source | Yes source | Not documented publicly source | Not documented publicly source |
| Simulation method (vendor's words) | Income Lab uses historical sequences or returns and inflation back to 1871; for plans too long for the data the software automatically produces a plan using the Traditional Monte Carlo analysis method instead. source | Deterministic engines compute every number; the Quantum Retirement Score's funding pillar is a seeded simulation of 2,000 paths over historical US market returns (1928–2025). source | Core tax calculations will continue to rely on a deterministic, algebra-based calculation engine. source | Monte Carlo simulations generate 1,000 return scenarios; the standard model uses the log-normal distribution model. source |
| Stress testing / historical scenarios | Real Historical Periods — Global Financial Crisis, Dot-Com Bubble, 1970s Stagflation, Great Depression. source | Three crisis scenarios calibrated to 2008, 2022, and 2020, applied holding by holding according to each product's contractual mechanics, with modeled recovery. source | Not documented publicly source | Probability of Success under scenarios like an immediate market drop, increased taxes. source |
| Withdrawal sequencing / guardrails | Risk-based guardrails; we then automate plan monitoring and notify you when a plan calls for a change. source | Dynamic guardrails on discretionary spending; taxable, then tax-deferred, then Roth. source | Not documented publicly source | Easily implement different withdrawal sequences into the plan and illustrate the impacts of any changes. source |
| Client-facing output | Client reports (listed in the Core plan). source | Client-ready presentations generated from the same analysis. source | A client-friendly, shareable report. source | Share the Snapshot with your client from the secure Client Portal or as a PDF. source |
| AI features (vendor's words) | Penny, a tactical planning tool augmented by AI. We don't do math with AI. The AI does not train on your client data. source | AI explains modeled results and drafts advisor-reviewed language; it does not compute, alter, or determine any financial projection. source | 2026 roadmap: apply artificial intelligence to reduce manual tasks and surface planning insights across tax and insurance. source | Iris AI Planning Agent — Double Check, Cash Flow Reviews, Plan Builder, Find Opportunities, Ask Iris Anything; Smart Import extracts plan data from uploaded documents. source |
| Tax-return upload / OCR | Upload a 1040 to Penny for a tax summary in seconds (Pro plan). source | Reads uploaded documents: statements and intake forms are read to pre-fill empty client fields, subject to validation rules and confidence thresholds. source | In under a minute, our OCR scans over a hundred pages; PDF files only. source | Tax Analyzer uses OCR technology to scan the tax return and redact sensitive data before saving files for your analysis (Premium and above). source |
| Published methodology page | Yes source | Yes source | Not documented publicly source | Help-center Methodology articles (Monte Carlo scenario generation, planned distribution method, state and local tax). source |
| Security statement (vendor's words) | SOC 2 (Type II) report available on request; all stored customer information is encrypted using AES-256. source | Client data encrypted on Google Cloud in the United States, never used to train AI, yours to export or delete. source | Our security program is informed by SOC 2 Type II and NIST frameworks. source | PII encrypted using AES-256; US-based data centers; SOC 2 listed among data-center accreditations. source |
| List price (vendor's words) | September 2026 published range $1,990–$3,588 per advisor per year, as of 2026-09-08 source | $379 per month for a solo advisor; firm seat pricing for teams — list price as of 2026-11-09. source | September 2026 household-based annual pricing from $749 (30 households) to $15,499 (750 households), as of 2026-09-08 source | September 2026 published range $1,799–$3,059 per advisor per year, as of 2026-09-08 source |
| Integrations named | Charles Schwab, Fidelity, Orion, Black Diamond, Redtail, Altruist, Nitrogen, Yodlee, PreciseFP, BridgeFT, Interactive Brokers, Millennium Trust, Blueleaf, fpPathfinder, SSG. source | Not documented publicly source | fpPathfinder, Zocks, Redtail, Jump AI, Wealthbox, Asset-Map, PreciseFP, Bento Engine, Kitces.com. source | RightCapital partners with dozens of companies — CRM: Redtail, SmartOffice, Wealthbox; custodians including Schwab, Fidelity and Pershing; performance reporting including Orion; portfolio analytics including Nitrogen and Morningstar Advisor Workstation. source |
In each vendor's words
Income Lab (Income Laboratory, Inc.)
Comprehensive financial planning. Built on deep retirement expertise. Software for financial advisors.
source · read 2026-11-09
Quantum Portfolio Analytics
Retirement income planning and Roth conversion software for financial advisors.
source · read 2026-11-09
Holistiplan
Holistiplan simplifies and scales tax planning to save time, deliver more value, and win clients faster.
source · read 2026-11-09
RightCapital
Easy-to-use software with powerful tools to simplify planning, enhance client engagement, and help advisors scale efficiently.
source · read 2026-11-09
About Quantum Portfolio Analytics
Quantum Portfolio Analytics is retirement income and Roth conversion planning software for financial advisors. Deterministic engines compute every score, projection and tax figure: identical inputs produce identical outputs, and the methodology for each engine is published on this site.
Every tax calculation applies tax year 2026 law for federal tax and all 50 states plus the District of Columbia, with Social Security taxation, required minimum distributions, capital-gains stacking and Medicare IRMAA tiers inside every projection. The tax methodology page names the IRS, SSA and state sources behind each table.
Multi-year Roth conversion options are sized to a federal bracket, priced year by year with the full tax engine and compared over a lifetime; the advisor chooses among the options. The same analysis produces client-ready presentations.
A large language model explains results computed by deterministic engines; it does not generate the figures and does not give investment advice. Narratives are reviewed by the advisor.
Built for fiduciaries: the product is designed to document the alternatives, assumptions and sources a fiduciary process requires. List price is $379 per month for a solo advisor, with firm seat pricing for teams, as of 2026-11-09.
Common questions
- Where do the facts on this page come from?
- Every statement about another vendor comes from that vendor's own public website or help center, quoted or closely paraphrased, with the page linked and the date it was read. Nothing is taken from review sites, rankings or third-party articles.
- What does "Not documented publicly" mean?
- The vendor's public pages we read on the date shown did not describe that capability. It does not mean the product lacks it. Vendors can request a correction using the address at the bottom of this page.
- Does Quantum Portfolio Analytics use AI to compute projections?
- No. A large language model explains results computed by deterministic engines; it does not generate the figures and does not give investment advice. Narratives are reviewed by the advisor.
- How does Quantum Portfolio Analytics handle state income tax?
- The tax engine recomputes federal and state income tax for every projected year across all 50 states and the District of Columbia, applying tax year 2026 law verified against IRS, SSA and state revenue department documents. The methodology is published on this site.
Sources
- https://www.incomelaboratory.com/ · read 2026-11-09
- https://www.incomelaboratory.com/tax-lab/ · read 2026-11-09
- https://help.incomelaboratory.com/faqs/does-income-lab-calculate-rmds · read 2026-11-09
- https://help.incomelaboratory.com/tax-lab-methodology · read 2026-11-09
- https://help.incomelaboratory.com/methodology/why-does-my-plan-switch-from-historical-to-monte-carlo · read 2026-11-09
- https://www.incomelaboratory.com/retirement-stress-test/ · read 2026-11-09
- https://www.incomelaboratory.com/retirement-gps/ · read 2026-11-09
- https://www.incomelaboratory.com/pricing/ · read 2026-11-09
- https://www.incomelaboratory.com/penny/ · read 2026-11-09
- https://www.incomelaboratory.com/methodology/ · read 2026-11-09
- https://www.incomelaboratory.com/security/ · read 2026-11-09
- https://www.incomelaboratory.com/pricing · read 2026-09-08
- https://quantumportfolioanalytics.com/about · read 2026-11-09
- https://quantumportfolioanalytics.com/methodology/roth-conversions · read 2026-11-09
- https://quantumportfolioanalytics.com/methodology/tax · read 2026-11-09
- https://quantumportfolioanalytics.com/methodology/simulation · read 2026-11-09
- https://quantumportfolioanalytics.com/methodology/stress-testing · read 2026-11-09
- https://quantumportfolioanalytics.com/methodology/ai · read 2026-11-09
- https://quantumportfolioanalytics.com/methodology · read 2026-11-09
- https://quantumportfolioanalytics.com/methodology/security · read 2026-11-09
- https://quantumportfolioanalytics.com/subscriptions · read 2026-11-09
- https://www.holistiplan.com/ · read 2026-11-09
- https://help.holistiplan.com/roth-projection-compare-all-brackets · read 2026-11-09
- https://help.holistiplan.com/how-does-holistiplan-handle-medicare-part-b/d-irmaa-income-related-monthly-adjustment-amount-surcharges · read 2026-11-09
- https://www.holistiplan.com/platform/tax-planning/ · read 2026-11-09
- https://www.holistiplan.com/platform/ · read 2026-11-09
- https://help.holistiplan.com/state-taxes-in-holistiplan · read 2026-11-09
- https://www.holistiplan.com/news/holistiplan-leads-tax-planning-software-category-with-39-market-share-in-t3-tech-survey-expands-workflow-automation-and-ai-capabilities-in-2026-roadmap/ · read 2026-11-09
- https://www.holistiplan.com/who-its-for/financial-advisors/ · read 2026-11-09
- https://help.holistiplan.com/ · read 2026-11-09
- https://www.holistiplan.com/about/why-holistiplan/ · read 2026-11-09
- https://www.holistiplan.com/pricing · read 2026-09-08
- https://www.holistiplan.com/platform/integrations/ · read 2026-11-09
- https://www.rightcapital.com/ · read 2026-11-09
- https://www.rightcapital.com/features/ · read 2026-11-09
- https://www.rightcapital.com/tax-planning/ · read 2026-11-09
- https://help.rightcapital.com/faq/client-portal/profile-faq/goals-faq/retirement-health-care-costs/retirement-healthcare-costs2 · read 2026-11-09
- https://help.rightcapital.com/knowledge-base/retirement/social-security/tax-on-social-security-income · read 2026-11-09
- https://help.rightcapital.com/knowledge-base/client-portal/profile/expenses/state-and-local-tax · read 2026-11-09
- https://help.rightcapital.com/knowledge-base/assumptions/monte-carlo-scenario-generation · read 2026-11-09
- https://www.rightcapital.com/snapshot/ · read 2026-11-09
- https://www.rightcapital.com/security/ · read 2026-11-09
- https://www.rightcapital.com/pricing · read 2026-09-08
- https://www.rightcapital.com/integrations/ · read 2026-11-09
Vendors: to request a correction to a fact on this page, email founders@quantumportfolioanalytics.com with the public URL that documents the change.
The information on this page reflects each vendor's public documentation as read on the dates shown and is subject to change without notice. © 2026 Quantum Portfolio Analytics. All rights reserved.